In May 2026, two golf-front homes on Winding Pine Trail in Alaqua Lakes closed three weeks apart. 3138 Winding Pine Trl sold on May 8 for $1,290,000, about $345 per square foot of living area, after 6 days on the market. On May 29, 3235 Winding Pine Trl, a 1999 home whose listing advertised views of the 12th fairway, closed at $1,175,000, about $276 per square foot, after 147 days.
Both homes are on the same street and the same Tom Fazio course. The second one took 141 more days to sell and closed about $69 less per square foot. Across the sales Stellar MLS recorded in Alaqua Lakes from May through October 2026, that pattern repeats. Golf frontage is the least dependable premium in this community. Water, a preserve behind the yard, and a house in the size range most buyers here are shopping set the price more consistently.
Twelve closings, sorted by what was behind the house
Alaqua Lakes has roughly 515 custom and semi-custom homes. Taylor Woodrow began developing the community in 1998, building continued through 2015, and builders such as Dave Brewer Homes, Signature Homes and Charles Ayers Construction put their names on individual homesites. Group twelve of the 2026 closings by what each listing said about the lot and the spread starts to make sense.
| Address | Closed | Price | Living sq ft | $/sq ft | Setting in listing | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4013 Bermuda Grove Pl | Aug 18 | $2,132,000 | 5,021 | $425 | Water and golf views | 4 |
| 3382 Fernlake Pl | Jul 17 | $1,699,000 | 4,001 | $425 | Water views | n/a |
| 1781 Oakbrook Dr | Jun 30 | $2,060,000 | 5,160 | $399 | Golf and pond views | n/a |
| 3226 Regal Crest Dr | Sep 29 | $1,175,000 | 3,131 | $375 | Conservation views | 3 |
| 3358 Horseshoe Bend Ct | Jul 31 | $1,415,000 | 3,870 | $366 | Backs to conservation | n/a |
| 2177 Alaqua Dr | Oct 13 | $1,835,000 | 5,205 | $353 | Golf, water, conservation | n/a |
| 3138 Winding Pine Trl | May 8 | $1,290,000 | 3,739 | $345 | Golf front | 6 |
| 3274 Oakmont Ter | Aug 13 | $995,000 | 2,905 | $343 | Wooded | 2 |
| 3345 Park Grove Ct | May 18 | $1,185,000 | 3,488 | $340 | Wooded backdrop | 5 |
| 3235 Winding Pine Trl | May 29 | $1,175,000 | 4,262 | $276 | Golf front, 12th fairway | 147 |
| 2405 Alaqua Dr | Jun 15 | $2,530,000 | 10,059 | $252 | Golf and water, 2.31-acre double lot | 29 |
| 3311 Horseshoe Bend Ct | Jun 12 | $1,560,000 | 6,259 | $249 | Private, wooded | 114 |
Every 2026 closing above $395 per square foot had water in the listing description. 4013 Bermuda Grove Pl is a 2002 Dave Brewer custom home on more than half an acre with a new roof in 2025, and it went under contract in 4 days. The conservation and wooded lots form the next tier, from $340 to $375 per square foot. Three of them sold in five days or fewer: 3226 Regal Crest Dr, 3274 Oakmont Ter and 3345 Park Grove Ct.
The two homes whose listings described a golf fairway and nothing else came in at $345 and $276. One landed level with the wooded homesites and the other sold far below them, and neither reached the water-view tier.
The same price split shows up in the current listings
The current listings follow the same split. In mid-November, the fastest contract in Alaqua Lakes was 2133 Alaqua Lakes Blvd, listed at $1,849,000. The home sits on a cul-de-sac with water and conservation views, backs to Wekiva Preserve, and went under contract after 3 days. 3413 Fernlake Pl, a half-acre golf-course homesite, went under contract at $1,845,000 after 35 days and a $50,000 reduction from $1,895,000.
On Regal Crest Drive, two homes on the 7th fairway were listed at the same time. As of mid-November, 3375 Regal Crest Dr was asking $1,445,000 for 3,601 square feet after 8 days, and 3387 Regal Crest Dr was asking $1,199,000 for 3,038 square feet after 56 days. The September sale of 3226 Regal Crest Dr, a conservation lot on the same street that closed at $375 per square foot in 3 days, is the obvious comparison for both.
Supply accounts for much of the gap. Much of the community lines the course, so a fairway view is common here, while water and a preserve backdrop are scarcer. Buyers in Alaqua Lakes have seen many golf-front homes and adjust their offers on condition and price. The homes that back to water or Wekiva Preserve have fewer close substitutes.
Past about 5,000 square feet, price per foot drops sharply
The second pattern in the table is size. The 2026 closings between about 2,900 and 5,200 square feet sold at $340 to $425 per square foot. The two largest were well below that. 2405 Alaqua Dr, a 10,059-square-foot home on a 2.31-acre double lot with golf and water views, closed in June at $2,530,000, about $252 per square foot. 3311 Horseshoe Bend Ct, at 6,259 square feet, closed at about $249 per square foot after 114 days.
The two estates now listed on Legacy Hills Court make the size question concrete. In mid-November, 3545 Legacy Hills Ct, a 10,684-square-foot home on 1.55 acres overlooking the 8th hole, was asking $4,125,000 after 218 days on the market and a $675,000 reduction from $4,800,000 on October 25. Next door, 3540 Legacy Hills Ct, with 12,006 square feet on a 1.2-acre double lot, was asking $4,499,000 after 157 days. Those asking prices work out to roughly $386 and $375 per square foot. That is the range the mid-size homes reached in 2026. The one 10,000-square-foot closing this year came in at $252.
Above $4 million, the number of people shopping for a home in Alaqua Lakes in any given month is small. Size adds dollars to the total price, but past about 5,000 square feet each added square foot brings much less. MLS figures compiled as of November 13, 2026 put Alaqua Lakes at about 3.2 months of supply on a trailing 12-month basis, with five active listings and two under contract. Most of that supply is at the top of the price range, where the buyer pool is thinnest.
For the wider picture, the Orlando Regional REALTOR Association's September 2026 report shows homes above $1 million across the Orlando region averaging 72 days on market, with sales closing at 95% of list price that month. In Alaqua Lakes, the mid-size homes on water and preserve lots did much better than that regional average. The largest estates did worse.
A golf view and club membership are separate purchases
Part of what a fairway buys in Alaqua Lakes is clearer once you look at who owns the course. The 18 holes inside the gates are The Legacy Club at Alaqua Lakes, a Tom Fazio design that opened in 1998 at 1700 Alaqua Lakes Blvd. Concert Golf Partners bought the club in October 2013, and it is run together with Heathrow Country Club as one membership. Golf Guide's January 2024 profile of Heathrow Legacy Country Club explains the background. For years the two private clubs, a couple of miles apart, competed for the same limited pool of members, and Concert bought Heathrow out of foreclosure in July 2011 before acquiring Legacy.
The club's membership page lists golf, tennis and social categories. The golf tier covers both courses, and prospective members are sent to the membership office for pricing. Alaqua Country Club is a different club. It opened in 1988 with a Gary Player course, has been principally owned by John Ritenour and his wife since 2009, and is invitation-only with a cap of 150 full members, according to its own history and membership pages. Buyers sometimes mix up the two because of the shared name.
Buying a home on the 12th fairway gets you the view of the 12th fairway. Club membership is a separate decision with its own office and its own price. That helps explain why the market paid less in 2026 for golf frontage alone than for water. A buyer who wants to play can join from any lot in Alaqua Lakes.
What the association's quarterly bill covers
The amenities that come with owning a home here belong to the Alaqua Lakes Community Association. According to the association's amenities page, they include a community pool, five Har-Tru tennis courts, a staffed gatehouse with 24-hour security, and a seven-acre park with a pavilion, fields, basketball, volleyball and a playground. Listings active or pending in November 2026 disclosed association fees of about $1,020 to $1,070 per quarter, with the guard, pool, private roads and recreation facilities named among the inclusions. Both Legacy Hills Court listings disclosed $2,654 per quarter. When you compare two Alaqua Lakes homes, put the fee each listing discloses next to its price. Those figures are listing disclosures as of November 2026, and the association's current bill is the number to rely on. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm costs for your own situation with the association and the right professional.
For buyers comparing Alaqua Lakes with the guard-gated villages across the county line, our look at why two Heathrow homes can be nothing alike covers how those fee layers stack up. The Alaqua Lakes neighborhood page has the current listings.
If you own in Alaqua Lakes and wonder where your home falls in this year's spread, from $249 to $425 per square foot, the answer depends on what is behind the lanai, how the square footage lines up with these closings, and how the house compares to the homes that sold in days. Eric Holt's appraisal background at Holt Real Estate means we price homes against comparable sales one at a time, not against a community median. Get a free home valuation and we'll show you which 2026 Alaqua Lakes sales match your home.